I’m really pretty amazed at the continued sparring over the comments Glenn Beck made a couple of weeks ago regarding social justice and the Church (see here and here). I sort of figured it would be something that would blow over after a day or two: another right-wing media figure spouting off some stupid remarks that get a fiery response from the Christian left and then after two days all that’s left is the smoldering embers on obscure blogs (like this one), but nobody really cares anymore.
What I find fascinating is that this one hasn’t burned away like previous ones. Glenn Beck, instead of retreating or apologizing or actually thinking about the absurdity of his remarks, has heaped more fuel onto the fire by continuing to insist and emphasize his claim that the term “social justice” or “economic justice” in the church is akin to “Marxism,” “communism,” and “Naziism” and that if you hear such terms spoken in your church, you should run and hide and report your church to “the authorities” (sounds more Big Brother-ish than anything he’s fighting against!).
Now, I don’t want to just be another blogger going off on a tirade about how wrong Glenn Beck is…I don’t want to be the guy who’s helping to heap fuel on the fire…and I’m not going to try and defend the place of “social justice” or “economic justice” in Christianity or in the Church (mostly because I think it’s pretty plain to see if you actually read scripture…try Deuteronomy 15, Leviticus 25, Amos, or Micah…or for those of you who prefer the words of Jesus himself, try Matthew 23 and 25 or the entire book of Luke)…and most of all, I’m not going to try and weigh in on the national health care debate, the so-called “wealth distribution,” or any other issue (even thought I have lots of opinions).
But in an era of highly polarized politics and religion, I just want to toss out the question: Who is speaking for you? Who is speaking for your Church?
Is it the Glenn Becks? Is it the Pat Robertsons? Is it the Conservapedias with their “conservative Bible project” (which is an abomination to me as an “aspiring Biblical scholar” and should be to anyone who wants to read the Bible well)? On the other hand is it the “social gospel”? Is it “tolerance”? Is it President Obama and the Democratic party?
Or is it Jesus? Do you (and your Church) stand above the polarized national debates and outside of American conservative/liberal culture to call out that culture wherever it needs to be called out?
I realize that most of the people that read this blog are probably a) my family or b) my friends who already mostly agree with what I think. And so maybe this is futile or simply worthless. But I’ve got to get something off of my chest…
Our current national dialogue—be it regarding politics, religion, natural disasters, or basically anything—is riddled with sensationalism, fear-mongering, mud-slinging, misinformation, personal and national arrogance, and a whole lot more. Every conversation, every issue is so clouded by hate and fear that there is no dialogue. But worst of all, you have a bunch of people who are given a pulpit from which to preach slander and sheer distortions of the truth and of the Gospel!
The Gospel I read is a message of restoration, redemption, and renewal. It is a story of hope and love and peace. It is the story of God turning the world upside down with the coming of his son and the bringing of his Kingdom to earth. That Gospel forces me to care about the poor and marginalized and to seek “economic justice” and “social justice.” It forces me to care about the environment, to seek the preservation of species, the reduction of pollution, and the sustainability of my lifestyle. It forces me object to wars and oppression. It forces me to sympathize, to understand and pursue relationship with those who are broken and sinful, even as I am broken and sinful. And it forces me to love those who disagree with me and to seek Truth and engage in civil dialogue and debate.
I’m pretty sure most people in the Church would agree with (most of) that. I’m pretty sure that most of those who identify themselves alongside Jesus were cringing at Rev. Robertson’s words regarding Haiti and that most would also disagree on some level with Glenn Beck. Yet, the mentality that they espouse—a mentality of suspicion, fear, individualism, selfish interest, American superiority, and capitalistic idealism—is destructive to the national dialogue, to the American Church, to the message of Jesus Christ, and to everything that we are called to be and do as Christians. If we continue to tacitly endorse these folks and others like them (even if we think they represent the extremes) by our attitudes, our actions, or television viewing, our money, or our theology, then we are in grave danger of totally misunderstanding who Jesus was and of getting in the way of the Kingdom of God coming to earth.
You don’t have to be a “Christian leftist,” a “liberal,” a fan of Jim Wallis and Sojourners, or a “socialist” to agree with that. You don’t have to give up Evangelical Christianity. You don’t have to like President Obama. You don’t have to give up on “conservative” stances on some issues such as abortion. But you do have to seek to love your neighbor and promote truth-seeking and -telling…and I’d suggest that you prayerfully consider how those might impact how you view some other issues on our national table.
Who speaks for you and your church? Be sure it’s Jesus.